| 2025 | Rip City USA |
| 2024 | Rip City USA |
| 2023 | Lancaster Heat |
| 2019 | Michigan Finesse |
| 2018 | MSW Hurricanes |
| 2014 | Central PA Angels |
| 2013 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2012 | Lady Rebels |
| 2011 | Miss Shen |
| 2010 | Pittsburg Power |
| 2025 | CANCELLED |
| 2024 | Team Pennsylvania |
| 2023 | Lady Dukes NJ Gold |
| 2022 | Newtown Rock |
| 2021 | Ohio Hawks |
| 2020 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2019 | Ohio Lasers |
| 2018 | Delaware Cobras |
| 2017 | Ohio Lasers |
| 2016 | Ohio Outlaws PA |
| 2015 | NY Diamonds Girls |
| 2014 | Amherst Lightning |
| 2013 | Amherst Lightning |
| 2012 | Pittsburgh Power |
| 2011 | New York Connection |
| 2010 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2009 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2008 | Long Island Bandits |
| 2007 | Lady Bandits |
| 2006 | Pittsburgh Spirit |
| 2025 | NY Starz- Burch |
| 2024 | Pittsburgh Passion |
| 2023 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2022 | Maddog's |
| 2021 | Electric City Bombers |
| 2020 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2019 | NY Intensity |
| 2018 | Team Long Island |
| 2017 | Ohio Storm |
| 2016 | Ohio Emeralds |
| 2015 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2014 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2013 | Motor City Madness |
| 2012 | WNY Sting |
| 2011 | Pittsburg Power |
| 2010 | Pittsburg Power |
| 2009 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2008 | Lady Bandits |
| 2007 | WNY Diamond Girls |
| 2006 | Central PA Krunch |
| 2025 | Pittsburgh Lady Roadrunners |
| 2024 | Ohio Cobras |
| 2023 | NY Inferno |
| 2022 | Adirondack USSSA Pride |
| 2021 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2019 | Michigan ICE |
| 2018 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2017 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2016 | Capital District Fusion |
| 2015 | Capital District Fusion |
| 2014 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2013 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2012 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2011 | Amherst Lightning |
| 2010 | WNY Sting |
| 2009 | La Nova Hybrids |
| 2008 | WNY Sting |
| 2007 | WNY Sting |
| 2006 | Pittsburgh Spirit |
| 2025 | UNY Revolution-Catalano |
| 2024 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2023 | Miss Shen Bombers |
| 2022 | Miss Shen United |
| 2021 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2019 | NY Inferno |
| 2018 | SC Hurricanes |
| 2017 | Easton Heat |
| 2016 | Cayuga Gamblers |
| 2015 | Cayuga Gamblers |
| 2014 | Quebec Rebelles |
| 2013 | Ajax Raiders |
| 2012 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2011 | Scarborough Rays |
| 2010 | Brampton Blazers |
| 2009 | Team Ontario |
| 2008 | Guelph Gators |
| 2007 | Amherst Lightning |
| 2006 | Cincinnati Elite |
| 2025 | Ava Roofing- Righetti |
| 2024 | Steel City Athletics |
| 2023 | Titans |
| 2022 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2021 | Lakeshore Legends |
| 2020 | Softball Central-Drayer |
| 2019 | Ohio Hawks |
| 2018 | Titans |
| 2017 | NY Diamond Girls |
| 2016 | Avalanche Fastpitch |
| 2015 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2014 | New Era Diamond Girls |
| 2013 | Bonetto Insurance |
| 2012 | Team Quebec |
| 2011 | La Nova |
| 2010 | WNY Empire |
| 2009 | Team Dong It |
| 2008 | WNY Empire |
| 2007 | Team WNY |
| 2006 | La Nova |